Charlotte Tilbury vs. NATURE REPUBLIC Oil Cleanser, Compared

Which of these skincare favorites should you use? We compare the two products based on their ingredients and safety information.
Notable Ingredients
BioNymph Peptide Complex, Hyaluronic Acid and Wild Pansy Extracts, Rosehip and Camellia Oils and Antioxidant Vitamin E
Vitamin E
Highlighted Skin Goals
  • Anti-Aging
  • Hydrating
  • Protecting
  • Protecting
  • Anti-Aging
  • Replenishing
Ingredient Safety
Paraben-free
Paraben-free
Sulfate-free
Sulfate-free
Environment Pollutant-free
Environment Pollutant-free
Paraben-free
Paraben-free
Essential Oil-free
Essential Oil-free
Alcohol-free
Alcohol-free
Sulfate-free
Sulfate-free
Silicone-free
Silicone-free
Environment Pollutant-free
Environment Pollutant-free
Potentially irritating (Dirty Dozen) ingredients
Fragrance: Fragrance (Parfum)
PEG: Peg-8
BHA & BHT: Bht
Siloxane: Cyclopentasiloxane, Phenyl Trimethicone
Fragrance: Fragrance
PEG: PEG-20 Glyceryl Triisostearate, PEG-10 Isostearate
BHA & BHT: BHT
Petrolatum: Mineral Oil
Allergy-inducing ingredients
Allergen: Hexyl Cinnamal, Benzyl Benzoate, Linalool, Hydroxycitronellal, Cinnamyl Alcohol
Allergen: Benzyl Alcohol
Environment polluting ingredients
-
-
Ingredient Safety by Skin Type
Good for Dry Skin
7
-
-
Good for Acne-Prone Skin
1
-
-
Bad for Sensitive Skin
4
-
Good for Dry Skin
1
-
-
-
-
-
Bad for Sensitive Skin
1
Bad for Acne-Prone Skin
1
Ingredient Safety Breakdown (EWG)
63% low risk
24
24% medium risk
9
11% high risk
4
3% unknown risk
1
56% low risk
10
33% medium risk
6
6% high risk
1
6% unknown risk
1