The smell choices are OK.
I had heard inklings of witch hazel being too harsh for long-term use, but it wasn’t until I started DMing and watching LAbeautyologist, who invented the 60-second rule, that I realized that this product was the cuss of my increased oil production. That day I decided to turn over a new leaf — hence the 1 star. Witch hazel is an ASTRINGENT and toners are supposed to restore skins pH so this isn’t a toner. I am grateful that finished the first bottle and the second one will work as a brush cleaner.
Great alternative: Heritage Store’s
Rosewater Facial Toner