I've never used an oil cleanser before and probably won't ever use one. The Fenty cleaner's texture is creamy and thick so when I apply it on my face, it really feels like a deep cleanse. Even then, if it's ever too thick you can always dilute it with water. I would most likely never steer to oil cleansers just because the product already works well to cleanse everything the first time around. I tested this with a full face of makeup - full coverage foundation, a couple layers of mascara, eyeliner, eyeshadow, etc. You can see the makeup coming off! Of course, they say to always double cleanse for makeup and it never felt stripping to my skin when I do. It's very gentle. If you have sensitive skin or just not in favor of fragrances, then sure, go for the oil cleanser. But then if I were to have such a product, I'd just use it to clean the bits that the Fenty cleanser didn't reach. If that's the case, then why not just use a micellar water product instead? I've used this product during summer and winter (right now!) - during my oiliest moments and my driest moments. It was never a problem for me :) Fenty Skin has very impressive formulas (with the exception of fragrance). The cleanser is the best selling product in their brand so I'll give credit where it's due - it works like a charm :) Hope that helps!